Blog

Can Medical Bills Be Eliminated in Chapter 7 Bankruptcy?

One of the things I've noticed over the years is that people who are struggling with medical bills often don't think of themselves as candidates for bankruptcy.

They may have always paid their bills on time. They may own a home, have a steady job, and have relatively little credit-card debt. Then someone in the family becomes ill, needs surgery, or has an unexpected hospital stay.

Before long, they're dealing with thousands of dollars in medical bills they simply cannot afford.

A question I sometimes hear is, "Can I file bankruptcy if most of my debt is from medical bills?"

The answer is yes.

In fact, medical debt is generally treated much like credit-card debt in Chapter 7 bankruptcy. If you qualify for Chapter 7, most ordinary medical bills can be discharged.

Medical Debt Is Generally Unsecured Debt

When someone files Chapter 7 bankruptcy, one of the first things we examine is the type of debt they owe.

A mortgage is secured by the home. A car loan is usually secured by the vehicle.

Medical bills are different.

Ordinary hospital bills, emergency-room charges, physician bills, ambulance charges, and unpaid medical expenses are generally unsecured debts.

That means there is ordinarily no property pledged as collateral for the debt.

For bankruptcy purposes, these debts are generally treated similarly to credit cards and personal loans.

If the debt qualifies for discharge, Chapter 7 can eliminate the person's legal obligation to pay it.

There is no special rule requiring someone to repay an ordinary hospital bill simply because the debt arose from medical treatment.

What If You Have Health Insurance?

Having health insurance doesn't necessarily prevent someone from accumulating substantial medical debt.

Consider a person who has employer-sponsored health insurance but undergoes surgery followed by several months of treatment.

Between deductibles, copayments, coinsurance, and services that may not be fully covered, the patient ends up owing $18,000.

At the same time, the person misses several weeks of work and begins using credit cards to cover ordinary household expenses.

By the time they contact our office, they may owe $18,000 in medical bills and another $25,000 in credit-card debt.

Chapter 7 may be able to eliminate both types of debt.

The important question isn't whether the debt is medical or credit-card debt. It's whether the person qualifies for Chapter 7 and whether the particular obligations are dischargeable.

What If the Medical Bills Have Gone to Collections?

This is another common concern.

A client may tell me that the original hospital bill was $6,000, but the account has now been transferred to a collection agency.

They sometimes assume that because the debt is in collections, it is somehow treated differently in bankruptcy.

Generally, it isn't.

An ordinary medical debt does not become nondischargeable simply because a collection agency is attempting to collect it.

Even if the medical provider has sold the account to a debt buyer, the underlying obligation is still generally an unsecured debt.

And if a medical creditor has already filed a lawsuit or obtained a judgment, the debt may still be dischargeable.

However, if the creditor has obtained a lien against property, that lien needs to be reviewed separately. Discharging the personal obligation does not automatically eliminate every valid lien.

Will Bankruptcy Stop Medical Collection Lawsuits?

In most cases, yes.

When someone files Chapter 7 bankruptcy, the automatic stay generally prevents creditors from continuing collection efforts involving debts incurred before the bankruptcy filing.

That includes most collection calls, lawsuits, wage attachments, and efforts to enforce judgments.

There are exceptions, particularly when someone has had previous bankruptcy cases dismissed within the preceding year.

But for a typical first-time Chapter 7 filer, the automatic stay provides immediate protection against most ordinary medical-debt collection activity.

Once the debtor receives a discharge, creditors generally cannot continue attempting to collect discharged medical debts as personal obligations.

That can be a significant relief for someone who has been receiving collection notices from several different medical providers.

What If You Are Still Receiving Medical Treatment?

This is something I would want to discuss carefully before filing.

Suppose someone has been receiving treatment from a physician for several months and owes the practice $4,000.

The person is still seeing that physician and expects to need additional treatment.

The outstanding pre-bankruptcy balance may be dischargeable, but bankruptcy does not require a private medical practice to continue providing every type of nonemergency treatment on the same terms indefinitely.

There are separate legal protections involving emergency medical treatment and certain other circumstances, but those issues should not be confused with the discharge of an unpaid medical bill.

It's also important to understand that bankruptcy generally addresses debts that arose before the filing date.

If someone receives new medical treatment after filing, the resulting charges are ordinarily new obligations.

This is one reason timing can matter when a person is facing continuing medical expenses.

What About Medical Bills Owed by a Spouse?

Suppose a married couple has $30,000 in medical bills resulting from one spouse's hospitalization.

Only the husband is considering filing Chapter 7.

Whether the wife's responsibility for those bills will remain depends on the circumstances.

Massachusetts law can impose liability between spouses for certain necessary expenses, including some medical expenses. The analysis may also depend on the agreements signed with the medical provider and who is legally responsible for the charges.

A bankruptcy discharge generally protects the individual who filed, not another person who may also be legally responsible for the debt.

Consequently, I would want to determine whether both spouses are responsible for the medical bills before recommending an individual or joint filing.

Do You Need a Certain Amount of Medical Debt to File?

No.

There is no minimum dollar amount of medical debt required to file Chapter 7 bankruptcy.

Someone with $15,000 in medical bills may have a legitimate reason to consider bankruptcy, just as someone with $75,000 in debt might.

But that doesn't mean bankruptcy is always the best choice.

If a person has one relatively small medical bill and little other debt, negotiating a payment arrangement, applying for financial assistance, or challenging an incorrect charge may be more appropriate.

Massachusetts hospitals may have financial-assistance programs, and patients should investigate whether they qualify for available assistance before assuming that every bill must be paid in full.

I generally want to understand the entire financial picture before recommending bankruptcy.

Medical Debt Shouldn't Be Ignored

One of the unfortunate things about medical debt is that it often arises through circumstances beyond a person's control.

Someone may be managing their finances responsibly and still end up with substantial bills following an illness, injury, or unexpected hospitalization.

The fact that the debt is medical doesn't make it less serious, but it also doesn't mean there are no options.

For someone who qualifies, Chapter 7 can eliminate many ordinary medical debts along with other dischargeable unsecured obligations.

At Common Law Associates, LLP, we help individuals and families throughout Cape Cod and southeastern Massachusetts evaluate their debts and determine whether Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 bankruptcy makes sense.

If medical bills have become unmanageable, it may be worth reviewing your options before collection lawsuits or other financial problems make the situation more difficult.